Stainless Steel Vs Carbon Steel

Discover the differences between stainless steel and carbon steel in terms of their properties and characteristics, which make them suitable for various applications. The table below provides a concise overview of both materials.

Table of Contents

  • Differences Between Stainless Steel and Carbon Steel
  • Heat Resistance of SS vs CS Grades
  • Machinability and Weldability of Stainless Steel vs Carbon Steel
  • Strength of Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel
  • Chromium Content in SS and CS
  • Why Is Carbon Steel Prone to Rust?
  • What Makes SS Rust-Resistant?
  • Hardness and Melting Points of Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel
  • Characteristics of Carbon Steel
  • Characteristics of Stainless Steel
  • Advantages of Stainless Steel
  • Advantages of Carbon Steel
  • Price Comparison of SS vs CS
  • Properties of Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel
  • Chemical Composition of Carbon Steel
  • Factors to Consider When Choosing Stainless Steel or Carbon Steel

Differences Between Stainless Steel and Carbon Steel

Feature Symbol Stainless Steel Carbon Steel
Composition Composition
  • High chromium content
  • Iron
  • Carbon
  • High carbon content
  • Iron
  • Trace amounts of other elements
Corrosion Resistance Corrosion Resistance
  • Highly resistant to corrosion and rust
  • Poor corrosion resistance
Strength Strength
  • Strong but softer than carbon steel
  • Stronger and harder
Hardness Hardness
  • Less hard than carbon steel
  • Harder due to higher carbon content
Weldability Weldability
  • Good weldability
  • Difficult to weld
Cost Cost
  • More expensive
  • Cheaper depending on grades
Ductility Ductility
  • Good ductility, can be bent without breaking
  • Lower ductility
Thermal Conductivity Thermal Conductivity
  • Lower thermal conductivity compared to carbon steel
  • Higher thermal conductivity
Finish Surface Finish
  • Superior surface with a lustrous finish
  • Dull, matte finish
Hygiene Hygiene
  • Easily cleaned, resists bacteria and pathogens
  • Contains hygienic and non-toxic qualities, but can corrode if not maintained properly
Lifespan Lifespan
  • Average lifespan of 20 years
  • Average lifespan of 20 years

View Heat Resistance of SS vs CS Grades

Below are key points regarding the heat resistance of stainless steel and carbon steel. This will give you a summary of their heat resistance under different conditions and temperatures.

SS vs CS Heat Resistance

Stainless Steel

  • Handles high temperatures well
  • Lower thermal conductivity
  • Retains its properties up to 1000°F
  • Effective even at high heat

Carbon Steel

  • Handles high temperatures as well
  • Higher thermal conductivity
  • Less heat-resistant than stainless steel
Heat Resistance of SS vs CS

Refer to Machinability and Weldability of Carbon and Stainless Steel

The following table provides detailed information on how both materials can be machined and welded, including the required speeds, tools, treatments, or conditions.

Machinability and Weldability of Stainless Steel vs Carbon Steel

Features Carbon Steel Stainless Steel
Machinability Easily machined Harder to machine
Weldability Good welding capabilities More challenging
Tool Wear Tools last longer Tools wear out quickly
Welding Processes Versatile with various methods Requires specific techniques and fillers
Cutting Speed Higher speeds possible Lower speeds needed
Surface Finish Good finish achievable Harder to maintain a good finish
Heat Affected Zone Less prone to distortion More prone to distortion; needs careful heat management
Post-Weld Treatment Less critical Often requires treatment to prevent issues

Carbon Steel is Stronger and More Durable Than Stainless Steel

Carbon steel contains up to 2.1% carbon by weight, making it stronger and more durable. The higher the carbon content, the harder and more durable the steel becomes after heat treatment.

In contrast, stainless steel has a lower carbon content, making it less hard than carbon steel.

Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel Strength

Tensile Strength
Carbon Steel Stainless Steel
Low carbon steel Medium carbon steel Alloy steel Austenitic Stainless Steel Martensitic Stainless Steel Stainless Steel Ferritic
60,000 to 80,000 PSI 100,000 to 120,000 PSI 150,000 PSI 72,000 to 115,000 PSI 72,000 to 160,000 PSI 65,000 to 87,000 PSI
Carbon Steel Tends to Have Less Chromium Content Compared to Stainless Steel

The table below provides details on how chromium content affects the properties of both materials and the benefits chromium provides.

Chromium Content in SS and CS

Feature Carbon Steel Stainless Steel
Chromium Content Contains less than 1% chromium Contains at least 10.5% chromium
Corrosion Resistance Less corrosion resistance due to lower chromium content Higher chromium content enhances resistance to rust and corrosion
Formation of Chromium Oxide Layer Limited or no protective chromium oxide layer Forms a thin, protective chromium oxide layer that prevents rusting
Carbon Steel is More Susceptible to Rusting When Exposed to Moisture

The following information explains why carbon steel is prone to rust when used in humid conditions.

Why Is Carbon Steel Prone to Rust?

Carbon Steel
  • Exposure to water (moisture)
  • Oxidation reaction
  • High carbon content
  • Due to high carbon content, it rusts and corrodes quickly

What Makes SS Rust-Resistant?

  • Air: Exposure to air can contribute to rusting
  • Saline: Saltwater or salty environments can lead to rust
  • Grease: Oil and grease can contribute to rust formation
  • Moisture: Prolonged exposure to moisture can cause rust
  • Strong Chemicals: Harsh chemicals can cause rusting
  • Heat: High temperatures over long periods can lead to rusting
SS Material

Hardness and Melting Points of Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel

Feature Brinell Hardness Melting Points
Stainless Steel Type 304: 201 MPa 1450°C
Ferritic Stainless Steel Grade 430: 180 MPa 1450°C
Martensitic Stainless Steel Grade 440C: 270 MPa 1450°C
Carbon Steel
Low-carbon steel 120 MPa 1450°C
High-carbon steel 200 MPa 1425-1540°C

Characteristics of Carbon Steel

  • Low carbon steel: 0.25% (e.g., AISI 304)
  • Medium carbon steel: 0.25% to 0.60% (e.g., AISI 409)
  • High carbon content: 0.60% to 1.25% (e.g., AISI 440C)

Characteristics of Stainless Steel

  • Corrosion resistance: Composed of chromium and iron (used for food and pharmaceutical containers)
  • Chromium: Ranges from 10% to 35%, depending on the grade

Advantages of Stainless Steel

Advantages:

  • Corrosion and rust resistance
  • Long lifespan
  • Hygienic
  • Recyclable
  • Temperature resistance
  • Versatile
  • Tensile strength
  • Low maintenance
Stainless Steel Application

Advantages of Carbon Steel

Carbon Steel

Advantages:

  • Versatility
  • Durability
  • Affordability
  • Recyclability

Price Comparison of SS vs CS

Type of Steel Cost Comparison Considerations
Stainless Steel More expensive than low or moderate-carbon steel. Best for applications needing corrosion resistance and high performance.
High-Carbon Steel More expensive than stainless steel. Used for applications requiring high hardness and strength
Low/Moderate-Carbon Steel Less expensive than stainless steel Cost-focused applications (where cost is a priority and corrosion is less of a concern)

Carbon Steel vs Stainless Steel Properties

Property Carbon Steel Stainless Steel
Tensile Strength 270-2100 MPa 200-200 MPa
Melting Point 1425-1540°C 1400-1510°C
Hardness 120-300 HB 140-400 HB
Density Low High
Corrosion Resistance Low High
Maintenance High Low
Durability Less High
Coefficient of Thermal Expansion 10-12 * 10-6/°C 10-17 * 10-6/°C

Chemical Composition of Carbon Steel

Low Carbon Steel
0.05-0.15
Medium Carbon Steel
0.3-0.5
High Carbon Steel
0.6-1.0
Ultra-High Carbon Steel
1.25-2

Factors to Consider When Choosing Stainless Steel or Carbon Steel

Factor Stainless Steel Carbon Steel
Cost More expensive Less expensive
Corrosion Resistance Superior resistant Less resistant
Strength and Hardness High strength Can be heat-treated for hardness
Maintenance Low maintenance Requires regular maintenance and protective coatings
This article aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the differences between stainless steel and carbon steel, focusing on their properties, strengths, and applications. Whether you're looking for a material that's corrosion-resistant or one that offers superior strength, this guide will help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

Drymix Mortar Admixtures

Drymix Mortar admixtures has wide range of products, including HPMC, MHEC, RDP, HPS, PVA.

Drymix Mortar Admixtures,Calcium Formate,Lignocellulose,Potassium Formate

Santo Chemical Limited , https://www.santchem.com

Posted on